From ddb9c9f603993a79d7ba8baf71bc0840ccc7639f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: wyn <1074145239@qq.com> Date: Thu, 16 Jul 2026 17:56:52 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?=E5=8F=82=E8=80=83=E6=96=87=E7=8C=AE=E4=BC=98?= =?UTF-8?q?=E5=8C=96?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit --- .../common/ReferenceRelevanceCheckService.php | 5 ++- .../service/ReferenceRelevanceLlmService.php | 32 +++++++++++++------ 2 files changed, 27 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-) diff --git a/application/common/ReferenceRelevanceCheckService.php b/application/common/ReferenceRelevanceCheckService.php index 9376932b..02bae704 100644 --- a/application/common/ReferenceRelevanceCheckService.php +++ b/application/common/ReferenceRelevanceCheckService.php @@ -581,15 +581,18 @@ class ReferenceRelevanceCheckService } $claims = $this->decodeClaimsJson(isset($row['claims_json']) ? $row['claims_json'] : ''); + $author_comment = $this->resolveAuthorCommentFromRow($row, $claims); + $author_comment = $author_comment?"[文献 ".intval($row['reference_no'])."]: ".$author_comment:$author_comment; $g['records'][] = [ 'check_id' => intval($row['id']), + 'reference_no' => intval($row['reference_no']), 'am_id' => intval($row['am_id']), 'status' => $st, 'is_relevant' => intval($row['is_relevant']), 'relevance_score' => $score, 'is_pass' => $isPass, 'reason' => (string)$row['reason'], - 'author_comment' => $this->resolveAuthorCommentFromRow($row, $claims), + 'author_comment' => $author_comment, 'combined_relevance_score' => floatval($row['combined_relevance_score']), 'combined_reason' => (string)$row['combined_reason'], 'cite_group_refs' => (string)$row['cite_group_refs'], diff --git a/application/common/service/ReferenceRelevanceLlmService.php b/application/common/service/ReferenceRelevanceLlmService.php index 219cff23..f186c5b4 100644 --- a/application/common/service/ReferenceRelevanceLlmService.php +++ b/application/common/service/ReferenceRelevanceLlmService.php @@ -464,7 +464,7 @@ Claim 具体内容见顶层 `claims`，combined_reason **只用字母指代**（ "is_relevant": 0, "relevance_score": 0.45, "reason": "系统综述，主语一致。Claim覆盖：A✔ B✔ C部分 D✘。类型部分匹配。因缺 D 且 C 仅背景，未达 0.65，故 0.45。", - "author_comment": "编辑意见：该文献与正文主张仅部分对应，关键论点仍缺直接证据。请改引更能支撑核心结论的文献，或补充说明引用依据。" + "author_comment": "该文献与正文主张仅部分对应，关键论点仍缺直接证据。请改引更能支撑核心结论的文献，或明确现有引用依据。" }, { "reference_no": 2, @@ -478,7 +478,7 @@ Claim 具体内容见顶层 `claims`，combined_reason **只用字母指代**（ **顶层 claims**：本引用组共用，只写一次；键为 A/B/C…（按实际拆解数量），值为各 Claim 中文具体内容。 **results 每条仅含**：reference_no、is_relevant、relevance_score、reason、author_comment。 -`author_comment` 规则：当 `relevance_score <= 0.65` 时必须生成（中文、**以期刊编辑审稿口吻**、礼貌可执行，**80–100字**）；当 `relevance_score > 0.65` 时必须返回空字符串 `""`。 +`author_comment` 规则：当 `relevance_score <= 0.65` 时必须生成（中文、**以期刊编辑审稿口吻**、礼貌可执行，**80–100字**，句尾需句号）；当 `relevance_score > 0.65` 时必须返回空字符串 `""`。 注意：`author_comment` 禁止出现 A/B/C/D、✔/✘、"Claim覆盖"、具体分值（如 0.65）等技术表达，需改写为作者易读的编辑批注。 **禁止**在 results 各条中写 combined_relevance_score、combined_reason、cite_group_refs、claims。 PROMPT; @@ -502,7 +502,7 @@ PROMPT; if ($abstractText !== '') { $parts[] = "【文献摘要/清洗后内容（Europe PMC·PubMed·Crossref·PDF）】\n" . $abstractText; } - $tail = '请严格按六步标准校对流程执行：①提取Claim→②提取文献证据→③Claim Mapping（✔/部分/✘）→④计算覆盖率→⑤判断支持类型→⑥输出分值与理由。先在 JSON 顶层 claims 写出各 Claim 具体内容（多事实背景句须拆出比较型/成因型/进展型/数据型独立 Claim），再对每篇文献给出单条 relevance_score（弱相关文献不得因联合抬高），最后写顶层 combined_relevance_score 与 combined_reason。results 每条只写 reference_no、is_relevant、relevance_score、reason、author_comment。author_comment 规则：score<=0.65 时输出以期刊编辑审稿口吻的中文批注（礼貌、可执行，80–100字）；score>0.65 时固定空字符串；author_comment 禁止出现 A/B/C/D、✔/✘、Claim覆盖、具体分值。禁止 reason_en、combined_reason_en、relevance_level、relevance_role、combined_is_relevant 等多余字段。'; + $tail = '请严格按六步标准校对流程执行：①提取Claim→②提取文献证据→③Claim Mapping（✔/部分/✘）→④计算覆盖率→⑤判断支持类型→⑥输出分值与理由。先在 JSON 顶层 claims 写出各 Claim 具体内容（多事实背景句须拆出比较型/成因型/进展型/数据型独立 Claim），再对每篇文献给出单条 relevance_score（弱相关文献不得因联合抬高），最后写顶层 combined_relevance_score 与 combined_reason。results 每条只写 reference_no、is_relevant、relevance_score、reason、author_comment。author_comment 规则：score<=0.65 时输出以期刊编辑审稿口吻的中文批注（礼貌、可执行，80–100字，句尾需句号）；若出现“建议补充/补充文献/补充说明”等措辞，需改写为“建议替换/改引/明确现有依据”，避免引导新增文献编号；score>0.65 时固定空字符串；author_comment 禁止出现 A/B/C/D、✔/✘、Claim覆盖、具体分值。禁止 reason_en、combined_reason_en、relevance_level、relevance_role、combined_is_relevant 等多余字段。'; if ($this->hasMixedReferTypes($referTypeMap)) { $tail .= ' 注意：本组为图书与期刊混排引用，务必按上方【各编号文献类型标注】分轨判断——图书/教材走「书目推断」轨（据书名、副标题、作者、ISBN、出版社判断主题，缺摘要不得默认 0.25）；期刊/原始研究走「摘要核对」轨（据摘要/清洗内容逐项核对 claim）。同组内两类分别按各自标准独立打分，切勿用同一把尺子。'; } elseif ($this->allReferType($referTypeMap, 'book')) { @@ -1612,28 +1612,28 @@ PROMPT; if ($authorComment !== '') { $authorComment = $this->sanitizeAuthorCommentText($authorComment); if ($authorComment !== '') { - return mb_substr($authorComment, 0, 100); + return $this->finalizeAuthorComment($authorComment); } } - $fallback = '编辑意见：该条参考文献与正文匹配度有限，关键论点仍缺直接证据。请改引更能支撑核心结论的文献，或补充说明引用依据。'; + $fallback = '该条参考文献与正文匹配度有限，关键论点仍缺直接证据。请改引更能支撑核心结论的文献，或明确现有引用依据。'; $reason = trim((string)$reason); if ($reason === '') { - return $fallback; + return $this->finalizeAuthorComment($fallback); } // 去掉显式分数结论，保留给作者可读的编辑批注 $reason = preg_replace('/Claim覆盖[:：].*/u', '', $reason); $reason = preg_replace('/故\s*(?:联合分?)?\s*[01](?:\.\d+)?[。.]?/u', '', $reason); $reason = trim((string)$reason); if ($reason === '') { - return $fallback; + return $this->finalizeAuthorComment($fallback); } $reason = $this->sanitizeAuthorCommentText($reason); if ($reason === '') { - return $fallback; + return $this->finalizeAuthorComment($fallback); } - return mb_substr('编辑意见：' . $reason, 0, 100); + return $this->finalizeAuthorComment($reason); } private function sanitizeAuthorCommentText($text) @@ -1647,12 +1647,26 @@ PROMPT; $text = preg_replace('/[✔✘]/u', '', $text); $text = preg_replace('/\b0?\.\d{1,2}\b/u', '', $text); $text = preg_replace('/\b\d{1,3}%\b/u', '', $text); + $text = preg_replace('/建议\s*补充/u', '建议替换', $text); + $text = preg_replace('/补充文献/u', '替换文献', $text); + $text = preg_replace('/补充说明/u', '明确依据', $text); $text = preg_replace('/\s{2,}/u', ' ', $text); $text = trim((string)$text, " \t\n\r\0\x0B;；，,"); return $text; } + private function finalizeAuthorComment($text) + { + $text = mb_substr(trim((string)$text), 0, 100); + $text = trim($text, " \t\n\r\0\x0B;；，,。"); + if ($text === '') { + return ''; + } + + return $text . '。'; + } + private function boolVal($v) { if (is_bool($v)) {